“Oh I don’t love you but I always will
Oh I don’t love you but I always will
Oh I don’t love you but I always will
I always will”
Have you ever had that moment? Where everything you thought you knew, every perception you had, every feeling, seemed in a moment of startling clarity to be false? It’s almost as if every decision, every moment flashes before your eyes and suddenly the pieces of the puzzle finally fit together and make sense. It’s strange, or perhaps not, that these moments of clarity always seem to happen to me just as I sit on the precipice of change.
Almost six years ago I had a moment like this, where I reevaluated everything I knew and all the plans I had. It would take four more months, but by the end of that time I had packed up my entire life, moved across the country and reinvented myself. It seems only natural then, that it is one of these moments that has me planning to pack up my entire life, move once again across the country, and reinvent myself. Or perhaps just return to the me I left behind.
While some things and people are easier to leave behind than others, it is in these moments that I also feel the strongest sense of loss. For the boy who couldn’t grow up enough to be the man I needed him to be. For the man who couldn’t be honest enough with himself and with me to realize what a bad idea we were from the start. For the friends who risked our friendship to take a chance at something more, who are no longer friends at all. Most importantly, for the ones who the timing was always wrong. The “what ifs” who could in fact be the biggest loss and the hardest to leave behind.
“You only know what I want you to
I know everything you don’t want me to
Oh your mouth is poison, your mouth is wine
Oh you think your dreams are the same as mine”
The process of saying goodbye to six years is a long one. You reminisce, you make some poor decisions in order to feel the connection that once was, and in some cases you realize how much you have overlooked a possibility, a situation, a person. I felt that way this weekend. Such a profound feeling of heartache and loss, but I haven’t lost anything that I know of. A man who is the closest I have to a best guy friend after the loss of my former guy friend at the beginning of the year. Someone who has known me for more than three years, who has been passionately obsessed with me, coldly indifferent of me, demanding my attention and hiding from me needing the same from him.
I’m not sure if it was the music we were listening to in our quest to create the perfect playlist, or the looming feeling of the inevitability of my departure, but something made a moment so electric, and yet so torturous that everything around us seemed to fade to black and white. There was only the two of us, our hatred, our adoration, our missed moments and the moments we would both rather forget. A beautiful mess, a relationship that never finished, but likewise never really started.
“I wish you’d hold me when I turn my back
The less I give the more I get back
Oh your hands can heal, your hands can bruise
I don’t have a choice but I still choose you”
When he kissed me I kissed him back with my entire being. Every touch was magnified a million times, and when I lay alone in my bed that night I felt close to tears, but I had no idea why. I still don’t. I’m not in love with him, but I grieve for the love that never was. I want him with everything I am and know that if that were to ever happen I would be unhappy and break both of our hearts. Such a strange mixture of fear, excitement and hope. I’m not sure if it’s him or me, maybe it’s just this precipice taunting me, waiting for me to jump. It’s a year of change, a year of starting over, a year of remembering what was and what could have been and loving every moment of the adventure along the way.
“Oh I don’t love you but I always will
I always will
I always will
I always will”
Poison & Wine is off of the album Barton Hallow by the Civil Wars. The group made up of singer-songwriter Joy Williams and John Paul White who met during a recording session in 2008. Since then they have been producing amazing music that recently got them two Grammy nominations for Best Folk Album and Best Country Duo/Group Performance categories. Their first full length album Barton Hallow have U.S. sales of more than 280,000 copies and 360,000 digital tracks.